Middle Ground: Our quest for the awesome homemade sourdough bread recipe

I've been making my own sourdough bread for about four years now. My sister and her husband got me hooked - they were making theirs for a while, and when I tried a slice, there was just no coming back. I was always a bread lover. Real bread though, the heavy, tasty kind, not the white fluff you usually get at the store.

<-- white fluff.... ^ happy-Sima bread

In the first two years, bread making was a struggle - the dough had to be kneaded, and left to rise twice at somewhat specific intervals, which made it harder to make during the workweek. The center did not always bake through, while the outside sometimes got too crusty. Then, two years ago, everything changed. I went back to my sister, and noticed that she did no kneading. So this time I listened carefully when she explained the process. I also combined her recipe with this one, from a blog written by a friend. The resulting recipe is what we've been following for the past two years, happy and content. Work time: 10 mins. Price: pennies. Results: awesome bread.

Not only that, but I've spread the goodness - I shared my sourdough starter with at least four people in the past year or so. One of them, a friend from work, has done no baking before. Within a few weeks, he was raving about the awesome bread he was getting. Another share, which happened on our travel from BC to NB, was at a bed and breakfast in Ontario. The hosts let me feed my starter in their kitchen and asked for a bit for themselves. A few days later, I got this email:

" I just wanted to tell you how much we’re enjoying the gift of your starter. I just put together the 3rd loaf and as yet have not started adding anything as we’re enjoying it so much just as it is!"

Anyway, enough talk, here's the recipe. It requires a starter. Which you can get from someone you know has one (like myself) or make your own (takes flour, water, and about 5 mins of work / day for a week or so, here's a recipe for a rye starter).

Things you'll need: whole wheat flour, white flour, starter, salt, water, large container with a lid (plastic bowl, large pot, whatever, as long as the lid fits well), spoon.

1) Combine 1.5 cups of whole wheat, 1.5 cups of white unbleached wheat, and a sprinkle of salt in a large bowl.

2) Mix the starter and pour in most of it into the bowl; leave about 1 inch of starter in the jar

3) Start mixing the dough, add water as needed to get a thick, but droopy dough. You don't need to knead at all, I only use a regular spoon to mix it; so if it's too difficult, add a little water. Cover and set on the counter to rise. You’re basically done. At this stage I also add sunflower seeds, walnuts, crushed chili peppers, olives, oregano, and all kinds of stuff, depending on the mood.

4) Add 1 cup of whole wheat to the starter, and add enough water to make it liquidy again. Stir well, cover with a cloth and leave on the counter for a few hours (I leave it out while the dough in the bowl is rising). That's when the starter is eating and getting bigger for next time. After the eating period (= when you put the bread into the oven), put it in the fridge (covered with a cloth, because the starter still needs to breathe). The starter stays in the fridge between breads; you just use it as is, cold and all. If it starts smelling weird, gunks up on the top or whatever, just scrape and discard the gunk, stir the starter, pour most out, feed, and let sit for a few hours to get bubbly again.

Left - just-mixed starter. Right - starter after a night of eating on the counter. Most of the flour is on top, trapped between gas bubbles from the starter's breathing.

5) Once the dough in the bowl is quite bubbly (2-3 h in the sun in the summer, or ~ 12 h in the cold of the winter), it’s time to bake.

6) Preheat the oven to 425 F (220 C, different ovens might be different; slightly change heat / time as needed through experimentation). Oil and flour a bread pan (or a cookie sheet, or a muffin tray). Gently pour the dough in, try to not squish the bubbles too much. Bake for 40 mins or until the crust is golden to your liking.